Leaving Behind a Beautiful Legacy of Sacred Tradition
In the Catholic Church itself, all possible care must be taken, that we hold that faith which has been believed everywhere, always, and by all.
—St. Vincent of Lérins
When we breathe our last breath, we will want to rest assured that we have left a legacy of truth, goodness, and beauty behind us. We will want to know that we have given our best to Our Lord and the wonderful world He placed us to dwell in. No matter what path we traveled in our lives, in the end, we will be truly grateful for every moment we have spent serving Almighty God and His people.
For priests such as Fr. Michael McMahon, SSPX, this beloved legacy has involved passing on the blazing torch of Sacred Tradition to future generations through authentic Catholic education.
“I am so grateful that I will leave behind me a legacy,” says Fr. McMahon. “God is never outdone in His generosity. For thirteen years, I was able to serve as the headmaster of La Salette Academy, and I could not have possibly been happier. I don’t think there was a happier person on earth than I was!”
Fr. McMahon sees that God’s providence was ever at work in his life, forming him for the mission He had set in store for him.
“I always had a great desire to teach and coach young men, and God fulfilled that desire in my heart,” he expresses. “I was given exactly what I wanted as the founder of the Academy. Presently, twenty-one of my former students are priests, nine are brothers, and three are Benedictines. There are presently twenty-one priests who have graduated from La Salette Academy, as well as a number of great Catholic professionals, and a lot of good, solid Catholic men raising strong Catholic families. It has all been worth it!”
Ultimately, by opening his heart to the grace of God and saying “yes” to the priesthood, Fr. McMahon has been able to bring the beauty, truth, and goodness of Sacred Tradition to countless souls. However, the “yes” did not come without a cost—he gave up quite a bit to respond to the call. He first sensed that God may want him to become a priest at a less than “ideal” time, one may say. He was a student at Yale University who had been recruited to play three collegiate sports. He had also recently been accepted into Yale Law School, and had even gotten engaged.
“I was on a fast track to power, which is what I was told Yale Law School is all about,” he says. “My fiancée happened to be two years behind me in school, so we had not gotten married yet, which was obviously very providential.”
As the Scriptures remind us, God works in mysterious ways for the good of those who love Him.
“I had a couple of weeks off from school, and my girlfriend was going to be gone during the second week, so I was wondering what I could do during that time,” he says. “Then, one Sunday when I was at home visiting my parents, I saw a flier about a men’s retreat that just happened to be taking place at the Society’s retreat house in Ridgefield, Connecticut, right during the week I had free. God takes all of these threads and weaves them together.”
And, thankfully, the good Lord never denies His grace to an open heart.
“So, in March of 1989, Our Lady gave me the grace to go on an Ignatian Retreat,” Fr. McMahon shares. “The whole retreat experience was like Saul getting knocked off his horse on the way to Damascus! It threw a wrench in my desire to ‘rule the world.’ During it, a priest asked me if I thought about a vocation, and I told him I had not. For quite a while afterwards, I could not get his question out of my head, so I finally decided to apply to the seminary.”
When a person is willing to make sacrifices for God’s greater glory, He returns the favors in abundance.
“I am not sure why I received such a grace, but one thing that could have made a difference is that in 1988, I gave up eating ice cream,” Fr. McMahon says. “It was just an inspiration. Everyone who knows me knows that was a huge deal for me, because I really love ice cream! In 1989, I also decided I was going to pray the rosary every day because I had gotten a little haphazard in doing so.”
After being accepted to the seminary, Fr. McMahon was blessed to study theology for three years in Écône, Switzerland. He was ordained in 1996.
Looking back, Fr. McMahon is profoundly grateful to his parents for nurturing an intense love in his heart for Christ and His Church.
“Everything in our home was judged according to the Catholic Faith,” he says. “My parents strongly emphasized excelling in academics as well as athletics, but we knew the Faith was definitely the most important aspect of our lives. They encouraged us to use the talents God gave us to the fullest and seek perfection in all that we did.”
With due diligence and fidelity, they helped him to truly appreciate authentic Catholicism and comprehend its place in the modern world.
“I was born in 1967, so I grew up during a difficult time in the Church, when the fruits of the Second Vatican Council were just becoming apparent,” he shares. “However, my parents were very well educated and solidly Catholic, and they knew how to navigate it all well. They recognized that there were problems in the Church, so they always made great sacrifices to attend the Latin Mass.”
In the end, God rewarded their efforts by endowing them with the gift of a priestly son.
“Any vocation usually begins with the family—usually a good, solid Catholic family—and this is where my vocation started,” he says. “My parents received many graces, and they responded to them. Our family was very blessed.”
Similar to Fr. McMahon, Fr. Nicholas Anthony Gardner, SSPX, finds that being a priest is an amazing way to leave an unforgettable legacy behind. As a religion teacher at Saint Mary’s Academy, he continues to labor arduously in God’s vineyard, planting a bountiful harvest that may be reaped for years to come.
“I teach catechism to boys in the eighth grade,” he shares. “It is a grade when their minds are first grasping difficult concepts. I love waking these powers up in their minds, so they can pray and believe more deeply, and defend the truths they discover before the world, out of loyalty to Our Lord Jesus Christ.”
Fr. Gardner also enjoys serving as the Chaplain of Saint Mary’s College in various capacities.
“Saint Mary’s College is an absolute powerhouse for Catholic culture, and the true value of the work being done here will only be shown in the centuries to come,” he says. “I respect and enjoy all of the students here, but I love seeing noble and gifted young men in particular, who prioritize a deep intellectual and spiritual formation at a time in their lives when there are so many competing forces. The investment they are making will not be measured in dollars, but in souls and a renewal of Catholic culture.”
When asked when he first sensed a love for the priesthood was being nurtured in his soul, Fr. Gardner recalls a deeply meaningful moment in his life.
“The very first time I remember looking to the priesthood with a strong admiration was when I was a boy, at the Offertory, giving the cruets to the priest I was serving for,” he shares. “It was the Sunday after our parish coordinators turned on him because of a disagreement, and then showed up that Sunday handing out literature outside the church on why people shouldn’t attend the SSPX. I realized that the priest is a man who sacrifices his life for others, even when they stab him in the back.”
Later in life, this love began to come to fruition when he took a leap of faith and devoted extra time to prayer.
“The first time it occurred to me that I myself could become a priest was when I went on an Ignatian retreat,” he says. “It caused me to laugh at the moment, and others would laugh in turn. My mother used to say that I would either end up a priest, or in prison—and she didn’t think I would be a priest!”
After opening his heart to this initial inspiration, God gave him all the graces he needed to pursue the Eternal Priesthood of Jesus Christ.
“Fr. Hewko (who has since left the SSPX) was the priest who tracked me down as a young adult, dismantled all my excuses, and inspired me to go to the seminary,” he says. “He took time to work with me in spiritual direction, and even tried to teach me a little Latin before I entered the seminary. I must say that I really don’t think I would be a priest if he hadn’t inspired and guided me. I pray for him often, and hope that he has the humility to admit the terrible mistake of the priests who have turned on their mother, the SSPX, and call themselves ‘The Resistance.’”
When asked what he loves most about being an SSPX priest, he responds:
“This is a tough question. I love everything (except paperwork). Each night after Compline, I pick a few things to thank God for, and it is never hard to find a new one. I love giving Communion and saying (in Latin) the words, ‘may the Body of Our Lord Jesus Christ preserve your soul unto life everlasting’ each time I give God to another soul.”
Even after years of being a priest, Fr. Gardner finds that the appreciation he has for his vocation only seems to grow.
“It never gets old,” he says. “I love the details of the Mass—like kissing the altar, and saying the name of a family member—or penitent, or server—at the memento. I love hearing confessions, and seeing how God works with souls with such patience and tenderness. I love giving spiritual direction for the same reason, and because souls are beautiful. It is humbling to work with souls who are manifestly better than you are—and it drives you to pursue holiness.”
Furthermore, Fr. Gardner has been deeply enriched by being involved with Adelante, a Catholic youth apostolate and outdoor pilgrimage program that contracts priests from the SSPX to provide the Traditional Latin Mass, sacraments, and spiritual direction. Adelante challenges young adults spiritually, mentally, and physically through demanding, engaging outdoor expeditions and adventures. Through it, he has been able to leave a legacy of leadership.
“It is a great treat to work with Adelante,” he shares. “Of all the apostolates I have been allowed to exercise, it is where I have seen the most impressive results—turning good Catholics into great ones, who will take responsibility for the common good. Leaders are so desperately needed, and Adelante is forming them in a sustainable way.”
When asked how his family and upbringing helped to prepare him for the mission God had in store for him, Fr. Gardner has some inspiring insights to share.
“Homeschooling was our only option, but I can see God’s Providence in that part of my formation, for sure,” he remarks. “My mother loved books, and we ran a bookstore as our family business, so we all grew up with a love of reading. She had a knack for fostering interests, and supplying books to feed those interests. This set us up for a different kind of intellectual life: one where we didn’t study because we had to, but because we wanted to.”
As a teenager, he developed a genuine desire to bring souls to Christ.
“I started studying religion intensely in high school, because I wanted to defend the faith before my Protestant friends, and hopefully lead them to the true religion,” he says.
He is thankful for the faith that his parents gave to him, as well as the profoundly Catholic environment in which he was raised.
“My mother was an English major, and a pro-life lobbyist, so we grew up with lively discussions at home,” he says. “Gardners weren’t allowed to not have a position on things of any importance, and if you couldn’t back it up with solid reasons, someone was going to let you know it. This atmosphere nurtured the development of solid principles and integrity in argumentation.”
Ultimately, no matter what kind of legacy Our Lord inspires us to leave behind, it will be one of tremendous love and reverence for Our Holy Faith, if we faithfully rely on His grace to bring it to fruition. There is much work to be done in the “devastated vineyard,” and if we do not do our part, the brilliant legacy we were meant to bring to life will never shine for all of eternity. As Archbishop Lefebvre once stated so eloquently in The Have Uncrowned Him:
The crumbled citadels have to be rebuilt, the bastions of the Faith must be reconstructed…The Blessed Virgin will have the victory. She will triumph over the great apostasy, the fruit of Liberalism. One more reason not to twiddle our thumbs! We have to fight more than ever for the social Reign of Our Lord Jesus Christ. In this battle, we are not alone: we have all the popes up through Pius XII inclusively. All of them combated Liberalism in order to deliver the Church from it. God did not grant that they succeed, but this is no reason to lay down our weapons! We have to hold on. We have to build, while the others are demolishing.
TITLE IMAGE: Pilgrimage to Oropa, Lorenzo Delleani (1840–1908). Pilgrims make their way through the misty Alpine landscape toward the celebrated Marian sanctuary of Oropa. Seen from behind and almost life-size, the figures lead the viewer into the lush mountain scenery, transforming a traditional religious pilgrimage into a meditation on faith, community, and the grandeur of nature.
